Unconstitutionality of the Finance Act 2023.

 


 Unconstitutionality of the Finance Act 2023

The Finance Act 2023 in Kenya has been declared unconstitutional by the Court of Appeal. This ruling, issued on July 31, 2024, found that the Act was fundamentally flawed due to significant violations of constitutional provisions, particularly concerning public participation in the legislative process. The court determined that the Act contravened Articles 220(1)(a) and 221 of the Kenyan Constitution and sections of the Public Finance Management Act (PFMA), which govern the budget-making process. As a result, the Act is considered void ab initio, meaning it was invalid from the outset.

Reasons:

The Court of Appeal's decision highlighted several key reasons for the unconstitutionality of the Finance Act 2023:

  • Lack of Public Participation: The Act was enacted without adequate public participation, failing to meet the constitutional requirement for engaging the public in legislative processes.
  • Violation of Budget-Making Process: The enactment process violated Articles 220(1)(a) and 221 of the Constitution and sections of the PFMA, which outline the necessary steps for the budget-making process.
  • Discriminatory Housing Levy: Section 84 introduced a housing levy that was discriminatory, failing to adequately distinguish between the formal and informal sectors.
  • Procedural Irregularities: The legislative process bypassed crucial stages, including the lack of concurrence from both houses of Parliament, further contributing to its invalidation.
  • Negative Economic Impact: The discriminatory housing levy exacerbated financial burdens on citizens in formal employment, creating broader negative economic impacts.

These reasons formed the basis of multiple legal challenges, including those brought by Senator Okiya Omtatah, who argued that the Act had been passed without proper adherence to constitutional principles. The court's ruling means that the tax rates and other provisions introduced by the Finance Act 2023 are now null and void, reverting the country to the provisions of the Finance Act 2022.

In summary, the Finance Act 2023 has been nullified in Kenya, marking a significant setback for President William Ruto's administration and its fiscal policies. The Court of Appeal's ruling underscores the importance of adhering to constitutional mandates and ensuring adequate public participation in legislative processes. This decision not only invalidates the Finance Act 2023 but also serves as a reminder of the critical role of constitutional compliance in the enactment of laws.


Book a Free consultancy with us here

Visit our website to learn more

Follow our pages Facebook , Twitter, Linked In , Instagram , TikTok


 


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Clarification On Taxation Of Meals Provided By Employers

Image
Background:  The Kenya Revenue Authority (KRA) issued a Technical Circular (Ref: 1005/1) in March 2017, outlining guidelines for the taxation of employment income, particularly regarding benefits provided to employees. Among these benefits, the circular stated that meals provided to employees up to a value of Kshs. 48,000 per year per employee were not subject to tax, in accordance with Section 5(4)(f) of the Income Tax Act. Clarification:  Recently, there has been confusion regarding the interpretation and application of this provision. The KRA has clarified that if an employer provides meals exceeding the value of Kshs. 48,000 per annum per employee, the entire value of the meal becomes taxable income for the employee. Essentially, any amount spent on meals beyond the specified limit is now subject to taxation under the Income Tax Act. Implications for Employers: This clarification places the responsibility on employers to ensure compliance with tax regulations regarding employee ben
Read more

Understanding Advance Tax: Essential Information for Vehicle Owners.

Image
  Welcome to the latest edition of the RWK & ASSOCIATES CPA(K) Newsletter. In this issue, we focus on Advance Tax , a critical requirement for all commercial and public service vehicle owners. Understanding how this tax operates and how to manage it effectively can save you time and avoid unnecessary complications. Advance Tax is a mandatory prepayment needed before a commercial or public service vehicle can be registered or licensed. The tax amount is determined by the vehicle's type and capacity. For example, vans, pick-ups, trucks, and similar vehicles incur a fee of Kshs. 2,500 per ton of load capacity or kshs 5000 whichever is higher. In contrast, saloons, station wagons, mini-buses, buses, and coaches are charged Kshs. 100 per passenger capacity per month or kshs 5000 annual amount whichever is higher. It is important to note that Advance Tax is not a final tax. Taxpayers must report this payment in their annual income tax returns and settle any additional taxes that
Read more

Summary Of The Key Proposed Changes In The Finance Bill 2024

Image
  Income Tax Act: • Introduction of Motor Vehicle Tax at 2.5% of the vehicle value payable upon insurance issuance. • Withholding tax on goods supplied to public entities at 3% for residents, 5% for non-residents. • Taxation of income from digital marketplaces/platforms at 20% for non-residents, 5% for residents. • Introduction of Significant Economic Presence Tax at 30% for non-residents. • Minimum top-up tax for resident entities in multinational groups. • Deductibility of SHIF, post-retirement medical funds, and the affordable housing contributions. • Investment deduction for spectrum license purchase at 10%. • An eco levy for manufacturers and importers will be introduced. • Imported motorcycles beyond a certain price will be taxed at 10% of value instead of a flat rate. • Taxation of interest income from infrastructure bonds for residents. Value-Added Tax Act: • VAT exemptions on bread will be removed. • Removal of VAT exemptions for financial services such as credit and debit car
Read more